Oak wilt has been confirmed a few blocks from a client's property. She has two large oaks: one has leaves with bristle-tipped lobes, the other has leaves with rounded lobes and no bristles. How should this identification shape the arborist's advice?
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: B. The bristle-tipped oak is in the red oak group, so it needs attention first
Bristle tips on the leaf lobes mark the red oak group, which includes northern red, northern pin and black oaks. A red oak that shows oak wilt symptoms usually loses most of its leaves and dies within about a month, while white oaks decline much more slowly and may survive infection. Swapping the two groups would send protective effort to the less vulnerable tree.
- A: Rounded lobes without bristle tips are typical of the white oak group, not the red oak group.
- C: Only the rounded-lobed tree fits the white oak group; the bristle-tipped tree is a red oak and is highly susceptible.
- D: Bristle-tipped versus rounded lobes is a standard way to separate red oaks from white oaks, and the groups differ sharply in oak wilt susceptibility.
Sources: Oak Wilt, Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources ; Virginia Tech Dendrology Fact Sheet: northern red oak (Quercus rubra), Virginia Tech Department of Forest Resources and Environmental Conservation ; Virginia Tech Dendrology Fact Sheet: white oak (Quercus alba), Virginia Tech Department of Forest Resources and Environmental Conservation
Report a problem with this question · ID ids-001